1994 MEETING MINUTES
22 June 1994
11:30AM 1:30PM
Cincinnati, OH
Peter Warner, Chairman, opened the meeting at 11:30AM
Agenda:
- Because of his absence from the June 22nd meeting, Sam Cha, Subcommittee
Chair, left a message to advise the EE-6 Committee that his findings regarding n-butanol
and the proposed substitute 2-butanol indicate that odor response to n-butanol was linear
over the lower concentrations (highest dilutions). In addition, Doug Anderson supplied the
committee with a two-page report that included a graph showing a 2-butanol/n-butanol odor
response comparison. The report will be distributed to the subcommittee for its review.
- Martha OBrien reported on progress on the generic procedure for use of an
olfactometer which will include the sample collection step. The procedure will be
presented at the 1995 international specialty conference in Minneapolis.
Some discussion of the proposed procedure followed:
- Airflow rate.
Martha indicated that normal breathing rate is 6-lpm and higher rates
may not be justified.
. Most agreed that sampling was very important to the relevance of
the result. Alex Gnyp suggested that a sampling rake should be used. Art Black cautioned
on condensation in the sampling bag, especially if it contains an oxidant (e.g. scrubber
exhaust).
- Pete Warner identified a goal on the part of the EE-6 Committee to offer to the AWMA
membership at the June 1995 meeting a one-half day session entitled "An Overview of
Odor Measurement and Control Technology" in order to provide coverage to odor-related
issues for the organization membership-at-large. Warner volunteered to chair, Sam Cha to
vice-chair the session. Subject material would be general and eclectic since most EE-6
authors would reserve more technical and specialized material for presentation at the
International Specialty Conference just a few months later in Minneapolis. Wayne Tutt,
Gary Gruwell, Ray Porter, and Richard Pope identified their interest in presenting
overview papers at this session. Sam Cha is interested as well. A Session Proposal Form
was submitted by Peter Warner to the AWMA Meetings Division showing the above title and
projected authors.
- Bill Prokop distributed copies of the proposed Minnesota Odor Regulation and discussed
its scope and implications.
Bill indicated the due to other higher priorities, the Minnesota Pollution Control
Association will not proceed with this revised regulation at this time. The revised
regulation is based upon a nuisance criterion of 10 odor complaints.
Much discussion followed about the relevance of this regulation to the EE-6 mission.
The general consensus was that providing assistance to state and local regulators was an
important role of EE-6.
It was suggested that the specialty conference include a session on odor regulations,
given its significance to EE-6.
- In the absence of Chuck McGinley, Program Co-Chairman of the 1995 International
Specialty Conference, Jon Swanson (Conference Program Co-Chairman) described their
progress on the Conference Speakers Program. Discussion of the Conference Title: Odors:
Indoor & Environmental Air, which had been arrived at by the Conference Committee
and provided to the National Headquarters was reviewed with the EE-6 Committee. EE-6
members suggested other titles such as: "Odors: An International Specialty
Conference", or adding the term "Ambient Air" or deleting "Indoor
Air". The Conference Committee agreed to take these suggestions under advisement,
allowing that the original title had not already been entered into publicity information
distributed by AWMA Headquarters. Jon Swanson acknowledged that the first Call For Papers
would appear in the July issue of JAWMA and read from his notes a list of topics which
would be included in this Call For Papers.
Adrianne Carolla, AWMA staff was presented at the meeting and indicated that the style
guide and specific requirements would be sent by headquarters to the authors of the
selected abstracts.
Bill Prokop asked about "exhibits" for the Minneapolis Conference and about
the request on the part of the EE-6 Committee (June 93 meeting) for exhibits of equipment
rather than publicity flyers. Warner replied that Linda Tanner, Minneapolis Conference
General Chairman, was planning exhibits and that Warner had forwarded to her a copy of the
1993 EE-6 Meeting Minutes to reflect the EE-6 Committee input. Program Co-chairman Jon
Swanson and Chuck McGinley had also seen this EE-6 Committee input. This input included:
- A list of recommendations for Program topics
- Other recommendations for the International Conference to include the need for quality
exhibits.
At J. Swansons request, several members present indicated interest in
participating in the 95 International Specialty Conference.
- As the meeting was coming to an end, P.Warner observed that after his term of three
years which ended in 1994, Vice Chairman, Martha OBrien (Chairman 1995) would take
over during next years meeting. It was therefore appropriate to take nominations for
the position of Vice Chairman. Alex Gnyp nominated Ron Poustchi, Dina Gnyp seconded, Art
Black moved that nominations be closed. With the only candidate, a voice vote elected Ron
Poustchi, Vice Chairman. Steve Ellis agreed to continue as Secretary.
Submitted by,
Stephen E. Ellis
Arthur D. Little
1994
EE-6 Odor Committee
Meeting Attendee List
Cincinnati, OH
| Stephen Ellis |
Arthur D. Little |
| Steve Colome |
IES |
| Tim ORourke |
EEC Eastern Michigan Univ. |
| Didier Languetin |
University of Quebec |
| Dina Gnyp |
Fluid Management, Inc. |
| Alex Gnyp |
University of Windsor |
| Ron Poustchi |
SBE Environmental Co. |
| Raymond Porter |
Camp Dresser & McKee |
| James J. Bertucci |
Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Chicago |
| John A. Lytle |
Burgess & Niple, Ltd. |
| Wayne Tutt |
City of Jacksonville, FL |
| Michael Dean |
New South Wales EPA, Australia |
| Bill Prokop |
PEC |
| Arthur W. Black |
Optimal Technologies |
| Dick Pope |
Malcolm Pirnie |
| David Finley |
Applied Sciences & Technology, Inc. |
| Ed Switala |
Owens-Corning Fiberglass |
| Gary Gruwell |
Dames & Moore |
| Jon R. Swanson |
Swanson Environmental, Inc. |
| Douglas Anderson |
Metropolitan Waste Control Commission, St. Paul |
| Armin Clobes |
S.C. Johnson Wax |
| Peter O. Warner |
Wayne County APC |
| Martha OBrien |
Odor Science & Engineering, Inc. |
| Julian Blomley |
Unocal |
| Adrianne Carolla |
AWMA Staff |
RETURN TO
MEETING MINUTES ARCHIVE

St. Croix Sensory, Inc.
This web site is sponsored and supported by St.
Croix Sensory, Inc.
Please contact the webmaster with any comments
about this site.

This site was last updated: 09/26/99